I always knew he was a boy, from the heaviness of his sleep when I carried him, which used to drive me to tears, and his father, my husband, soon to be ex-husband, or maybe not, used to say: ‘He’s just sleeping.’ When he finally woke up and kicked me , I wouldn’t have minded if he broke my rib.
So began our dance of me worrying about him and he kicking me back, to give him some space. I forced myself to let him be a boy. A real boy. From the first time he got on a bike and just peddled away to the time he drove a car by himself at age 13 on an LA Boulevard with my sly Tennessee friend Mary-Ellen next to him. No grotesque amusement park ride ever too scary, no wave ever too daunting, always purple-lipped and shivering by the time he would be pulled from a frigid pool, swearing he’s not cold, not hungry, just having a blast and seeing no reason for the fun to stop. There were broken bones, ER visits, the usual stuff–and at each step I resisted my urge to place him inside a plastic bubble controlled by a hand held radio-steering device that never left my hand.
All through the 90s, the Upper West Side mothers had one battle cry that I always cringed at:
Sitting not on the edge of the sandbox but often inside it, negotiating every shovel and pail dispute, they would coo:
“Use your words, Dylan, use your words.”
Boys were absolutely not supposed to exhibit aggression. I found it perverse. I knew enough to know I had to let him go, and let him find the line between boldness and self protection, if he was to break free of me, which of course I would have preferred he didn’t, but I curtailed that beastly urge. I reminded myself that he is not a parcel, not “mine.”
He wanted life with all it had to offer, since he could talk. The only thing that scared him was spiders, and what he called ‘the funny feeling,’ he got when he thought about time having no end, and the choice between being “deleted” or existing forever, neither of which appealed.
Jesus.
“Mom,” he said, at age 4, out of the blue, when we were taking a walk, “I need to get some friends who know what they’re doing.” I laughed for an hour. All his life, he’s seen me get felled, my feet tangled, mud sprayed, opportunities dashed, humiliations delivered, and an over-arching sense of never having or keeping the football, like Charlie Brown. He, on the other hand, would not, by mutual agreement, identify with it. He was a born leader, impossibly popular, yet gentle and compassionate, aware that I had cursed him with a keen sense of pathos–the two of us suddenly weeping over a turkey in the oven and imagining its mother, or he making me dig in the sawdust at the end of hamster Dusty’s life to see if she was still alive. Every half hour.
When he and his friend Alexander were about 8, we were at a lake in northern Connecticut, and they wanted to jump off a water tower into the lake. Alexander’s mother, Gully, said no way, it’s too dangerous. They stood scowling, and soon a little stocky girl in a bathing suit came over, blithely climbed the tower, and dove into the lake. I turned to Gully: ‘Now we have no choice. A girl did it. We have to let them.”
So we did. And off they jumped, about 200 times over the next few days.
He is now 14. He is my sole reason for waking up each day and continuing to try to turn the grounded vessel of my life around, to continue to believe in vanishing notions of getting life right, carrying on, starting over. There are few mistakes I haven’t made, few moments I can recall where I am able to approve of or even understand what I did.
Except for him.
Last week, two mornings in a row, he was unusually silent in the morning. He showers for half an hour, earning him his Native American name, Longshower, and he didn’t reply to my shouts through the door telling him what time it was.
On Friday he slept over at his friend Jake’s house, like he usually does. When he came home on Saturday, we were scheduled to take a bus upstate to see my sister. He walked in with a black eye, a fat lip, and a swollen hand.
“I was in a fight,” he said. I looked him over. “I think that might be broken,” I said, examining his hand.
I sat him down and he told me the story: A bully had been harassing him and his friends near their old school yard where they still hang out, for weeks. He challenged the bully to hit him, finally, and when he did not, he whispered an epithet that means coward, and walked away. The bully sucker-punched him in the jaw, from the side, and he saw stars. He stewed for a day, then sent word out that the bully should meet him in the yard on Friday after school. All very West Side Story: My son’s gang accompanied him, instructed not to intervene, and eventually the kid showed up, with his crew. My son had inquired in advance whether the bully might have a knife or a gun and was told he did not. My head spun, hearing of all this going on totally unbeknownst to me. “Why didn’t you tell me?” I howled.
“Because you would have told me not to fight him,” he said matter of factly.
They pummeled each other for what he thought was about three minutes, until somebody called the cops, and the sound of the sirens caused them all to scatter.
“Anyway, I feel better,” he said. “I was so angry, and now I’m not.”
We missed our bus. I started crying. Somehow all the pent up tension of 15 years of living with this heavy love, this helplessness, lack of control, spider-web faith that he would be protected and make sound choices out there, caught up with me.
We arrived upstate and my sister Bibi drove us to the nearest ER, where they told us he had two broken bones in his hand, and bandaged him up. As he lay there on the gurney, so skinny, with his big feet and his AC/DC T shirt, I remembered the very first time he stopped my heart. I was four months pregnant and was being attended to by an elderly MD who told me: “You are a healthy 27 year old pregnant woman, nothing is wrong with you,” as if addressing the ever increasing neurosis in our culture that pregnancy is an emergency.
“I know,” I said.
But on that second visit, the elderly doctor held a stethoscope to my stomach and went stiff.
Nurses were called in–they couldn’t find his heartbeat. I lay there praying, and tears trickled into my ears and time and space dissolved, until finally somebody shouted that they had found it again. I didn’t even know how much I wanted him–I had been somewhat angered to find myself pregnant, never thinking I was female, quite, escaping this condition by way of becoming a traveling journalist on the hunt, unencumbered, crossing Africa, covering world events, propelling myself with ideas and ideals I thought were incredibly important.
Where did the past 15 years go?
He shifted in the gurney and we talked about the new Kanye West record, and his hopes for it.
The doctor came in and gave my son a speech, about the importance of using language to de-escalate conflicts, not violence.
“I think he’s right, ” I said, when he left.
My son reminded me that years ago, I had told him that if you “have to punch a bully in the nose” if you want the problem dealt with. I did remember saying this–clearly an acting out of my own thwarted bully dreams, all the times I never got to hit back. “Since when do you listen to me?” I said.
How do you thank God enough, when you are able to walk out of a hospital with your son in bandages, and suddenly you are connected to all the mothers through all the ages who weren’t so fortunate? How do you take that gratitude, and promise God anything he wants so long as your one important prayer is always answered?
I know: It was just a fight in the school yard. But what if he wanted to go join the army and go fight a war? This to me, is the mystery, how the mothers survive the nights of war, not knowing. After all they have done to protect him and keep him safe. But part of the job is making him a “man” and instilling the notion of values, sacrifice, courage and valor, which all become a hopeless blur anywhere except in the movies.
I know there is some ancient Greek playwright who addressed all this.
The security guard said: “That guy is gonna come back. Did you mess him up? He’s gonna come back. You got to watch your back.”
I started reeling off prohibitions about where he could traverse between now and next Easter.
“I didn’t mess him up,” said my son. He said that for my sake. And it brought up an image of the other kid, in a bathroom, his own mother fumbling for bandages and peroxide.
My father had a good line, when I told him what happened. He drew a deep breath.
“Tell Jeremy we’re proud of him. But enough already.”

{ 1 trackback }
{ 10 comments }
My two boys in the US Marine Corps would like to thank you for that story.
Now they know their Mom is not the only one.
*hugs*
I love you, Celia Farber. You get the "best mom" medal from me without question.
(No offense to the other moms, including my own sons’ wonderful mom, I’m just sayin’.)
I don’t see a thing wrong with the way Jeremy handled the situation. If he had not gone back to face the bully, then there was a good chance that the bully would have made his life miserable until he did.
I had some experience with bullies when I was 14. In this case, it was a group of black kids (actually, almost all of the black males at the school were involved) at school who decided they were in control and went about harassing as many white kids as possible. Most of us were good, quiet kids who never bothered this group at all. Back then, I was fairly shy and reserved except when around friends and family. I suspect that’s why I was among the "chosen". The bullying went on for most of the year.Â
One morning, while preparing the bench press in the gym, I was struck across the back of my thighs with a weight belt. I turned around to see who had hit me and there stood one of the two "leaders" of this pack. He said "Whatcha gonna do, white boy?". I did nothing. When the coach asked what happened, I told him and he just said it was no big deal.
Finally, some time in April of that year, my parents were picking me up from school one day when one of my good friends ran to the car (I had grown up since kindergarten with him and his twin brother). He said told my dad that "those guys are after my brother". My dad told him to get in and we took off down main street. We saw my friend’s brother going in to one of the local stores and just as he started in the door, the same guy who hit me with the belt hit him in the back of the head. Dad threw the car in park in the middle of the street and he and I followed them in.
When we got into the store, all the employees had vacated the area and there was my friend, surrounded by about eight black guys.. Now my father is a very, very loud man and a Marine Corps Vietnam Veteran. He can get some looks on his face that would scare Satan himself. All he did was yell "HEY!" at the top of his lungs. Those guys couldn’t get out of that store fast enough.
Amazingly, I never had any more trouble after that (and neither did my two buddies). The black guys told some people that my dad was a "crazy ass honky" that scared the shit of them and figured I was just like him. The next year, another good friend of mine confronted another of the leaders, beat the crap out of him, and threw him into a trash can. He turned and asked the rest of the group if they wanted any and they declined. After that, no one had any more trouble with those guys.
The moral of the story is that bullies, whether they are in the school yard or are terrorists only understand one thing – violence.
I regret not defending myself and I spent almost an entire year of school in fear. Jeremy did the right thing. I wish I had done it, too.Â
TexasAg03′s last blog post..Stossel on Government Bailouts
Great story, Celia! Your son will no doubt grow up to be a fine man — mostly because of your efforts, too.
Best, HB
Thank you Texas. Love that Dad story.Â
Robert Avrech, a blogger and a noted screenwriter, tells his own bullying story here.
Well, as Marlon Brando once said to his son, Christian,
after he was found guilty of putting a bullet in his brother-in-law’s brain said:
"Sometimes, you just gotta duke it out."
There is something hidden in what Celia is writing here, at least if I’m not missing something. Which is that there is something beautiful, ennobling, and endearing in the masculine soul: at its worst it picks on the innocent, but at its best it protects the innocent fiercely. Including itself, if need be. Or its mom. ;-)
This is not just a boy/girl thing; the truth is that if you talk to enough girls, you know that women can be incredibly vicious toward each other as well as toward men. There’s an old adage, "boys are mean with their fists, girls are mean with their mouths," and I really think that’s a truism: it’s not true everywhere and always, but it seems to describe reality: boys are mean with their fists, girls are mean with their mouths.
Standing up to the bully is a hard thing to do. It’s also a valourous and noble and wonderful thing. Same for the girl who stands up to the gossip-squad that’s all over her.
Some say it’s insecure and crass, but I think "fuck you" are two of the most empowering words in the English language.
Celia, I have my share of political differences with you, but when you write about this stuff, I’m just in awe of you.
I’m a stay at home dad right now, raising two daughters (6 yrs and 18 mons). I hope I do as good a job of raising them as women as you do of raising your boy as a man. My greatest fear is failing them. You provide me inspiration.
I have to agree with Aziz, this was a great post. Thanks for sharing.
Usually if your hand is the part of you most hurt, that means you won the fight.Â
OTOH, it also implies he doesn’t really know how to throw an effective punch. I would suggest a boxing, karate, or judo program. We boys generally take to these like fish to water.
As they say: peace through strength. Punching a bully may get him off your back, but knowing how to fight often means not having to. Just moving into any kind of prepared stance and putting on a game face is usually enough to deter harassers.
Adults generally find it pretty easy to avoid even casual violence like shoving. Unfortunately, for kids too often the state monopoly on legal violence doesn’t exist (especially in our awful public daycare "school" system). Some conflicts come down to a choice between submission and fighting, and some of us will never choose submission.
Comments on this entry are closed.